China’s recent equity market surge, with an influx of over $13 billion in dedicated funds, has sparked considerable attention from global investors. Meanwhile, Indian markets have seen a modest $107 million in inflows, leading some to suggest a potential “Buy China, Sell India” trade. However, while China’s recent rally may seem impressive on the surface, the underlying issues of the Chinese economy paint a more complex picture.
Unresolved Structural Challenges in China
Despite the recent positive market sentiment, China continues to face significant challenges. A major area of concern is the country’s housing sector. The collapse of its real estate market has left tens of millions of housing units vacant, with estimates suggesting as many as 90 million empty homes. This surplus of unsold property is a direct result of over-construction in the housing market, which now constitutes roughly a third of the Chinese economy. The shrinking population and dwindling manufacturing productivity further exacerbate the issue, making it unlikely that these homes will ever be occupied.China’s credit bubble is another alarming factor. Over the past decade, private sector credit has surged to levels that echo those seen in Japan before its lost economic decade in the 1990s. The nation’s debt-to-GDP ratio has expanded significantly, adding vulnerability to an already fragile economy. Harvard professor Kenneth Rogoff has highlighted that China’s credit expansion could lead to a severe economic downturn if left unchecked, similar to what happened in the U.S. during the 2008 financial crisis.State-funded investments now account for an astonishing 42% of China’s GDP, double that of most advanced economies. While these investments have driven growth, they have also created overcapacity in manufacturing. This excess capacity, coupled with weak domestic consumption, forces China to rely heavily on foreign markets for its surplus output. Without a shift away from debt-fueled growth and over-reliance on state investments, China could face a prolonged economic slowdown.
Why the FIIs Are Rotating Towards China—For Now
The recent surge in Chinese equities can be attributed to the Chinese government’s efforts to stimulate economic growth, along with investor optimism about China’s dominance in electric vehicles (EVs), semiconductors, and artificial intelligence (AI). With 60% of global EV sales happening in China, the country’s position as a manufacturing hub for these cutting-edge technologies is undeniable. However, these sectors are not enough to offset the deep-rooted economic imbalances.The influx of foreign institutional investors (FIIs) into Chinese markets over the last few weeks seems like a tactical play, benefiting from China’s current undervaluation. However, this rotation could be short-lived. The Chinese economy still faces long-term risks, including bad debts, incomplete real estate projects, and political interventions that stifle entrepreneurial innovation and growth. Investors may be lured by the short-term potential, but the long-term viability remains questionable.
India’s Strong Fundamentals
While FIIs may be momentarily attracted to China, India’s fundamentals remain robust, warranting the premium valuations that Indian markets continue to command. Unlike China, India’s economy is not plagued by excess debt or over-reliance on state-led investments. Indian companies are driven by strong domestic consumption and supported by favorable demographic trends, regulatory changes, and policy shifts.India’s financial markets have demonstrated resilience, with steady inflows from domestic investors. While foreign inflows may fluctuate based on global market sentiment, the underlying strength of India’s economy keeps it in a favorable position. The key for Indian investors is to focus on companies with strong balance sheets, consistent cash flows, and a track record of sharing profits with minority shareholders.Furthermore, India’s regulatory environment is stable, and its corporate governance standards are improving. This makes India an attractive long-term bet, particularly for investors seeking exposure to emerging markets with less geopolitical risk than China. Companies that are asset-light and positioned to capitalize on structural growth trends, such as manufacturing and digital infrastructure, remain strong candidates for investment.
Conclusion: A Temporary Rotation, Not a Long-Term Shift
In conclusion, while China may be seeing a short-term rally, its long-term economic challenges are far from resolved. The housing glut, excessive state-led investments, and rising debt levels are significant risks that could undermine China’s growth prospects. In contrast, India’s fundamentals remain solid, backed by strong domestic demand, regulatory support, and favorable demographic trends.For long-term investors, India continues to offer a compelling growth story, despite short-term volatility. The recent FII shift towards China seems more like a tactical rotation rather than a strategic overhaul. India’s premium valuations are justified, given its resilient economic framework and the opportunities it presents for sustained growth.
Market this week
30th Sep 2024 (Open)
04th Oct 2024 (Close)
%Change
Nifty 50
₹ 26,061
₹ 25,015
-4.0%
Sensex
₹ 85,209
₹ 81,688
-4.1%
Source: BSE and NSE
The market ended its three-week gaining streak, posting its largest weekly decline since June 2022 amid rising geopolitical tensions.
Weak domestic data, a hawkish tone from Fed Chair Powell, and new SEBI F&O rules further dampened investor sentiment.
FIIs sold equities worth Rs 40,511.50 crore, while DIIs countered with purchases worth Rs 33,074.39 crore.
All sectoral indices closed in the red, with BSE Realty down 8%, BSE Auto shedding 6%, BSE Telecom falling 5%, and BSE Energy declining nearly 5%.
Weekly Leaderboard
NSE Top Gainers
NSE Top Losers
Stock
Change (%)
Stock
Change (%)
JSW Steel
▲
3.22 %
Reliance Ind
▼
(9.15) %
Infosys
▲
0.60 %
TATA Motors
▼
(7.86) %
Tech Mahindra
▲
0.45 %
HDFC Life
▼
(7.44) %
TATA Steel
▲
0.12 %
Bharat Petroleum
▼
(7.36) %
Hindalco Ind
▲
0.10 %
SBI Life
▼
(7.33) %
Source: BSE
Stocks that made the news this week:
VIP Industries surged up to 8% on October 4 following its partnership with Unicommerce to enhance its post-purchase e-commerce operations. VIP Industries, a leading manufacturer and retailer of luggage products in Asia, aims to streamline order processing across online channels through a single integrated dashboard.
Bank of Baroda climbed 4% to Rs 255 per share on October 4 after releasing its Q2 FY25 business update. The bank also announced plans to divest its Oman operations to Bank Dhofar, as part of its strategy to streamline international operations.
Bajaj Finance dropped over 3% on October 4 after reporting its Q2 business update, which showed the slowest AUM (Assets Under Management) growth in the past six quarters, causing investor concerns.
Disclaimer: This document is not intended for anyone other than the recipient. The contents of this document may not be reproduced or further distributed to any person or entity, whether in whole or in part, for any purpose. If you have received the publication in error please notify the sender immediately. If you are not the named addressee, you should not disseminate, distribute or copy this document. You are hereby notified that disclosing, copying, distributing or taking any action in reliance on the contents of this information is strictly prohibited. All non-authorised reproduction or use of this document will be the responsibility of the user and may lead to legal proceedings. This document has no contractual value and is not and should not be construed as advice or as an offer or the solicitation of an offer or a recommendation to take action in consonance in any jurisdiction. Finwizard Technology Private Limited (“Fisdom”) makes no guarantee, representation or warranty and accepts no responsibility or liability for the accuracy or completeness of the information and/or opinions contained in this document, including any third party information obtained from sources it believes to be reliable but which has not been independently verified. In no event will Fisdom be liable for any damages, losses or liabilities including without limitation, direct or indirect, special, incidental, consequential damages, losses or liabilities, in connection with your use of this document or your reliance on or use or inability to use the information contained in this document, even if you advise us of the possibility of such damages, losses or expenses. Fisdom does not undertake any obligation to issue any further publications or update the contents of this document. The information stated and/or opinion(s) expressed herein are expressed solely as general commentary for general information purposes only and do not constitute advice, solicitation or recommendation to act upon thereof. Fisdom does not have regard to specific investment objectives, financial situation and the particular needs of any specific person who may receive this document. The information contained within this document has not been reviewed in the light of your personal circumstances. Please note that this information is neither intended to aid in decision making for legal, financial or other consulting questions, nor should it be the basis of any investment or other decisions. Fisdom may have issued other similar documents that are inconsistent with and reach different conclusion from the information presented in this document. The relevant offering documents should be read for further details. You should make such researches/inspections/inquiries as it deems necessary to arrive at an independent evaluation of companies referred to in this document (including the merits and risks involved), and should consult its own advisors to determine the merits and risks involved. Fisdom makes no representations that the offerings mentioned in this document are available to persons of any other country or are necessarily suitable for any particular person or appropriate in accordance with their local law. Among other things, this means that the disclosures set forth in this document may not conform to rules of the regulatory bodies of any other country and investment in the offer discussed will not afford the protection offered by the local regulatory regime in any other country. Past performance contained in this document is not a reliable indicator of future performance whilst any forecasts, projections and simulations contained herein should not be relied upon as an indication of future results. The historical performance presented in this document is not indicative of and should not be construed as being indicative of or otherwise used as a proxy for future or specific investments. The relevant product documents should be read for further details. Fisdom does not undertake any obligation to issue any further publications to you or update the contents of this document and such contents are subject to changes at anytime.
Share the article
Array
Get exclusive content
and expert advice
Subscribe to fisdom to get regular updates in the finance world delivered to your inbox each month
